Whole Milk and Childhood Obesity – New Study Challenges Long-Standing Dietary Advice
Key Takeaways:
- Children who consumed whole-fat milk in early childhood showed lower odds of living with obesity in later childhood compared with those consuming reduced-fat options
- The study found no evidence that whole milk increases adiposity, challenging decades of low-fat dietary guidance
- Researchers suggest milk fat may influence satiety and overall dietary patterns, although mechanisms remain unclear
Rethinking milk fat and childhood health
New research from the University of Toronto suggests that children who consume whole-fat milk during early childhood may have a lower likelihood of living with obesity in middle childhood than those who drink reduced-fat milk.
These findings contribute to a growing body of evidence indicating that lower-fat milk may not provide the protective effect against childhood obesity that has long been assumed. For several decades, dietary guidelines in many countries have promoted low-fat dairy products. For example, Canada’s Dietary Guidelines in 2019 continued to recommend reduced-fat options, reflecting a broader historical focus on reducing dietary fat intake.
Study overview and design
The study, published in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, is described as one of the most comprehensive analyses to date examining the relationship between milk consumption and childhood obesity over time.
Researchers, including former postdoctoral fellow Tara Zeitoun and doctoral student Zheng Hao Chen, analysed data from the CHILD Cohort Study. This large, prospective study tracks health data from thousands of children from before birth through to adolescence.
Caregivers reported the type of milk consumed by children, including skim, one per cent, two per cent, and whole-fat milk. Researchers then assessed a range of outcomes at ages five and eight, including:
- Body mass index (BMI)
- Waist-to-height ratio
- Fat mass
- Preclinical and clinical obesity status
Key findings
Milk consumption was common among participants, with over 90 per cent of children consuming milk before the age of five. Among these:
- 24 per cent consumed whole-fat milk
- Approximately half consumed less than one cup per day
Despite relatively modest intake, notable differences emerged. Children who consumed whole milk at age five had significantly lower BMI at age eight. They also had 69 per cent lower odds of living with obesity compared with children who consumed skim milk.
In addition, researchers identified a broader pattern in which higher milk fat content was associated with more favourable adiposity profiles.
Expert insight
Kozeta Miliku, a professor of nutritional sciences at the University of Toronto’s Temerty Faculty of Medicine and a researcher at the Joannah and Brian Lawson Centre for Child Nutrition, emphasised the implications of these findings:
“The most important learning from this study is that whole milk was not associated with higher adiposity or obesity risks risk in children, and may even be linked to healthier growth patterns,”
She also highlighted the limitations of focusing narrowly on fat reduction:
“Switching to lower-fat milk has been about cutting fat in the diet, but that may miss the bigger picture,” says Miliku. “When we think about healthy growth, it’s important to consider the overall nutritional context. Removing fat does not automatically make skim milk a healthier choice for children.”
Implications for public health guidance
The findings raise important questions about long-standing public health recommendations. Prior to 2019, Health Canada advised that children transition from whole milk to reduced-fat milk from the age of two. Similarly, the Dietary Guidelines for Americans 2020–2025 supported reduced-fat dairy intake.
However, recent policy developments suggest a shift in thinking. In the United States, the Whole Milk for Healthy Kids Act has allowed full-fat milk to be reintroduced into school lunches, aligning with updated national guidance that is more permissive of full-fat dairy.
Possible biological mechanisms
While the study did not directly investigate underlying mechanisms, the researchers proposed several hypotheses:
- Milk fat may enhance satiety, potentially reducing the consumption of energy-dense, nutrient-poor foods
- It may influence overall energy balance
- It could play a role in metabolic pathways linked to growth and nutritional status
These potential explanations highlight the complexity of dietary patterns and suggest that focusing on single nutrients may overlook broader physiological effects.
The need for further research
Miliku noted that additional research is needed to better understand how milk fat may influence obesity risk and whether any protective effects persist into adolescence and adulthood.
With Canada’s 2019 dietary recommendations offering limited specific guidance on milk consumption for children, the study’s findings may help inform future discussions among parents, clinicians, and policymakers.
A broader view of healthy diets
Miliku concluded by reinforcing the importance of overall dietary quality:
“Whole fat milk can be part of a healthy diet and does not on its own increase obesity risk,” she adds. “And it’s important to think about the overall quality of the diet – the fruits and vegetables, whole grains and protein-rich foods they consume.”
Funding and support
The research was funded by the Canadian Institutes of Health Research and the Joannah & Brian Lawson Centre for Child Nutrition at the University of Toronto, supported through a donation by President’s Choice Children’s Charity.
CCH insights:
This interesting new research will hopefully be the trigger for governments and public health bodies to review and amend their outdated advice to choose low-fat dairy options instead of full-fat. The reductionist approach to nutrition, which considers food just in terms of calories and individual nutrients, is an oversimplification which does not help our understanding of the relationship between food and health. If the best food for children early in life is whole milk, why would it be beneficial for them to suddenly switch to low-fat milk at the age of 2?
Read More